Historic Converted Church c.1894

Own a Piece of Baltimore History: A Stunning Renovated 19th-Century Church!

A once-in-a-lifetime opportunity awaits discerning buyers with this meticulously restored 19th-century church transformed into a breathtaking residence. Located in Baltimore’s coveted Evergreen neighborhood bordering Roland Park, this historic gem offers a harmonious blend of old-world charm and modern luxury.

The architectural splendor of the original church is evident throughout the home. Soaring 20 foot ceilings adorned with exquisite stained-glass windows create an ethereal atmosphere, while original hardwood floors whisper tales of the past. The spacious living area, bathed in natural light from a magnificent skylight, is perfect for entertaining guests or simply relaxing in elegant surroundings. A gourmet kitchen, complete with custom cabinetry, granite counter tops, and top-of-the-line appliances, offers a culinary haven for the aspiring chef.

Upstairs, a dramatic loft and a spacious primary suite with a luxurious en-suite bathroom provide a private retreat. Two additional bedrooms and a beautifully renovated full bath are located on the main level. A versatile bonus space offers endless possibilities for customization, whether it be additional bedrooms, a home office, or storage. Step outside to a private rear courtyard, ideal for outdoor entertaining or gardening. Convenient off-street parking is accessible via alley access.

This extraordinary property was once the residence and studio of renowned artist/sculptor Tylden Streett, adding a touch of artistic allure to its rich history. The church steeple bell still rings, serving as a constant reminder of the building’s storied past.

Situated in the heart of the Evergreen community, this exceptional home offers the perfect balance of historic charm and modern convenience. Enjoy proximity to schools, shopping, and transportation while experiencing the tranquility of a secluded oasis.

ROOMS

1st Floor
Vestibule – Original wood floor, stain glass window, wainscot, built-in bench, double doors to front porch, oversized door to Living Room.
Great Room  – Original wood floor, oversized front door with ornate wood surround, fireplace with ornate wood mantel and surround, firewood pass-through door, wainscot, 20’+ vaulted ceiling with large skylight, 4 hanging lamps, custom curtains, 10 large stain glass windows, round window near ceiling ridge.
Kitchen/Dining Room – Original wood floor, tall built-in vintage mirror, custom cabinets with many unique features, granite counters, ceramic tile back splash, double sink, brass fixtures, stainless steel THOR appliances, 6 burner gas range with cook plate & dual ovens, granite center island, wood paneled vaulted ceiling, 2 ceiling fans, 2 hanging lamps, 2 wall sconces, recessed lighting, 4 large “tip-out” windows, round window near ceiling ridge.
Bedroom 1 – Original wood floor, closet, 1 window.
Bedroom 2 – Original wood floor, closet, 1 window.
Bathroom – Ceramic tile floor, granite counter, brass fixtures, claw foot bathtub, ceramic tile back splash, 1 window.
Storage/Recreation Room – Original wood floor, wainscot, door to alley, 3 windows. (potential bedroom suite or office)
Laundry – Original wood floor, washer & dryer, door to courtyard, additional water/sewer hook ups near window, 1 window.

2nd Floor
Primary Bedroom Suite – Original wood floor, vaulted wood paneled ceiling, ceiling fan, wood paneled half wall, Mitsubishi wall AC, overlook to kitchen, sliding privacy wall, bell pull for steeple bell (works), 2 closets, custom curtains, 2 arched windows, 1 round window near ceiling ridge.
+Bathroom – Ceramic tile floor, oversized marble double shower, hanging lamp, custom cabinets, marble counter, tile backsplash, 2 sinks, brass fixtures, commode room, 1 window.

Select Seller Upgrades & Improvements

• Removed Maple tree in alley
• Restored rear laundry room west wall
• New shake shingles outside
• Insulated Laundry ceiling
• Installed floor joist insulation under the Laundry and the great room
• Repaired French drains
• Installed door to patio access
• Restored bell and functionality
• Restored original 2nd concrete steps to front door
• Privacy fence on northside
• Remodeled main bath added free standing claw foot tub; Cast Iron
• New plumbing fixtures and water saver toilets
• Tile and custom woodwork in main bath
• All new custom cabinets kitchen and baths
• Matching 5 panel solid wood doors throughout home
• Custom matching door headers throughout home
• Added closet in bedroom 2
• Sound dampening and insulation between loft and downstairs bedrooms
• Restored custom wainscot in downstairs bedrooms
• Custom oversized kitchen with high end appliances (chef’s dream)
• Plenty of storage including bar side cabinets
• Farm style split kitchen sink
• Custom granite countertops with timeless tile backsplash and inlaid design
• Dining and kitchen lighting
• Added 2 closets in loft
• Master closets are stain grade finish and built in shelving, shoe storage and a full length mirror
• Built TV cabinet in master bed that matches existing wood work
• Custom tile and cabinets in master bedroom including motion night light
• Marble shower with bench and cubby’
• Matching 2 part custom baseboards throughout home
• French door to great room
• Built self contained wood burning fireplace
• Custom fireplace stone and wood work that matched original home design
• AV cabinet built in to fireplace for future TV projector (Pipe up to ceiling for wiring)
• New paint throughout home
• Locking firewood wall pass-through
• 20′ tall blackout curtains with sheers in great room
• Remote controlled dimming grand chandeliers in great room
• Many priceless original pieces including stain glass windows, floor to ceiling mirror, bell etc

HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE

Evergreen MP Church

The Evergreen church at 4622 Keswick Road began with Sunday worship under an oak tree near the location where the church is now. The over 300 years old oak stood in a backyard near the church till 2023 when it started dying and had to be taken down. On February 13,1895, the church was officially started with 13 members. The cornerstone was laid November 14, 1894, with the Rev J. W. Gray of Hampden M.P. Church preaching. The church was an important and active part of the community. Because of declining attendance in later years, the church merged with the Roland Avenue Methodist Church in June 1970, and the building was sold as residential in 1971, and officially decommissioned as a church.
more>>>>

Sculptor Tylden Streett

The building sold to sculptor Tylden Streett (1922-2019). He lived in the church till 2013. Tylden Streett remodeled the church to create an expansive studio in the front, with large north facing roof windows, partial open first floor, and a living space in the former events space at the rear of the building. He left many original details in place and re-used wood panels and other details throughout the rest of the house. He also kept the original paint colors on the outside. For many years his studio was unheated, and in wintertime Tylden Streett would build a large wood frame the size of a small room and would place the wooden structure over the artwork he was working on. He covered it with plastic on all sides to keep himself warm with just a space heater inside.
Mr. Streett had an interesting life as detailed in his obituary (Baltimore Sun).
more>>>>

Evergreen Community

Evergreen is historically significant because it was the earliest suburban development in this large area of numerous estates.. It was a rare example of early non-row house suburban style, albeit modest homes. Legend has it that Evergreen’s  mostly frame, narrow, individual buildings, were occupied by the builders and tradesmen who served Roland Park during its major period of construction from about 1895-1910.

The modern designation of Evergreen refers to two parcels of land historically known as Evergreen and West Evergreen. It  was the first development in this area and greatly antedated Roland Park. The entire area is enclosed by Oakdale Road on the north, Stony Run Park on the east, Cold Spring Lane on the south, and Maynadier Lane on the west.

In 1813 a Cockey family heir inherited 264 acres of the original colonial tract called “Ridgely’s Whim.” This property included all that was to become Evergreen. In 1864 Mrs. Fendall sold 20 of these acres to Allen A. Chapman. This land was bounded by Mrs. Jones “Cedar Park,” by Kyles family land, and by an avenue 30 feet wide. Two men named Brooks and Barton bought this and three other parcels from Mrs. Chapman in 1873. Soon after, the property was “developed”.

Or so the story was told until Evergreen’s 150th anniversary in 2023. Since then we’ve uncovered the true story of Evergreen’s founder: Charles Jerold Hull.

In West Evergreen the Victorian, often 14-foot wide houses were built on approximately 90 lots. The Evergreen property was subdivided into about 170 smaller lots that fronted on the three side streets.. Some of these were later combined and resubdivided to face Wilmslow Road.

By 1898 about 25% of the building lots had been improved, a few with stone and brick structures. The Evergreen Methodist Episcopal Church had been built at the north end of Cedar, and a public school existed on Schenley Road. An Electric Light Co. was in operation at the east end of Kendall Rd. near the Baltimore and Lehigh Railroad (which eventually became the Ma & Pa).
more>>>>

LINKS
Evergreen Community – Evergreen.org
Sculptor Tylden Streett – Baltimore Sun

MEDIA FEATURES
Baltimore Banner – Featured July 20, 2024
Zillow Gone Wild – Instagram Post
Baltimore Sun – “Hot Property” August 4, 2024

MEDIA CREDIT
R/E Pro Photos

This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed.